Navigating the AI Maze: Addressing Misinformation in the 2024 Elections in India and the USA

The upcoming 2024 elections in India and the United States bring to light the significant role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in shaping electoral processes. While AI integration enhances campaign dynamics and voter engagement, it also introduces notable concerns regarding misinformation, voter manipulation, and election security.

In 2024, 4.2 billion voters will face elections influenced by AI-driven misinformation, identified in the Global Risks Report 2024 as a critical threat to the stability of societies. This era, marked by misinformation about election processes and targeting of marginalised communities, heightens risks to democratic integrity. Since 2020, misinformation, including claims of a stolen presidential election, has spread unchecked on social media, endangering election officials and misleading voters. Congressional action, social media accountability, and comprehensive voter education are imperative to mitigate these threats and preserve the integrity of elections.

KIn India, the widespread use of AI-driven platforms presents a dual challenge of providing information and disseminating misinformation to a large portion of the electorate, particularly due to the country’s high social media penetration. Addressing the rapid spread of misinformation through AI tools is crucial, requiring measures that combat falsehoods while preserving free speech and authentic political discourse.

Similarly, in the United States, the landscape is complex, characterised by the proliferation of disinformation propagated by political elites, the pervasive use of AI technology, and reduced efforts by social media companies to curb misinformation. This environment is exacerbated by political and social unrest, declining trust among citizens, and limitations on academic research into disinformation. Both countries grapple with ethical concerns surrounding micro-targeting, where AI analyses extensive data to deliver tailored messages to specific voter segments. While micro-targeting can enhance engagement by providing relevant information, it also raises apprehensions about manipulation and polarisation.

The necessity for updated regulatory frameworks to address AI’s role in elections is evident. Transparent and accountable deployment of AI in political campaigns and election management is essential. Additionally, efforts to bolster election integrity through enhanced cybersecurity measures are imperative to guard against AI-driven threats like hacking and electronic voting interference.

Furthermore, safeguarding democratic values is paramount. Strategies focusing on protecting these values and fostering an informed electorate are essential. This includes educational initiatives to raise awareness about the potential misuse of AI and collaborations among technology experts, policymakers, and civil society to develop a balanced approach to AI usage in elections.

In 41 percent of cases, AI picture generators can produce misleading images that represent things like candidate health problems or electoral fraud.

As both democracies confront the complexities introduced by AI, the forthcoming elections serve as significant tests of their ability to effectively manage the dual challenges of misinformation and electoral integrity. A balanced approach is necessary, respecting individual freedoms while ensuring the collective security and fairness of the electoral process.

In the upcoming Indian elections, the integration of AI and digital technologies is set to enhance traditional campaigning methods. Political parties are effectively blending robust online campaigns with traditional in-person rallies, utilizing AI to extend the impact and reach of rally content across digital platforms like WhatsApp and social media.

However, this technological advancement is overshadowed by concerns regarding the use of state resources for Narendra Modi’s campaign, particularly through initiatives like sending WhatsApp messages through the “Viksit Bharat Sampark” , a contact listed as a verified Business on WhatsApp. These messages, which purportedly sought feedback on the government’s performance, were distributed using official government channels, posing potential ethical and legal issues. This approach demonstrates a deeper integration of state mechanisms with political campaigning, raising international concerns about privacy and the inappropriate use of personal data.

Moreover, the extensive exchange of data between government bodies and private brokers highlights the urgent need for stringent data protection laws, a need that the current Digital Personal Data Protection Act does not sufficiently address. The Election Commission of India’s lack of action on these pressing issues reflects a worrisome disregard for the challenges of digital campaigning, such as micro-targeting and the influence of social media, thereby risking the integrity of the electoral process. This context also resonates with the global challenge of political misinformation, as seen in India with Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s remarks during an election rally, which have been criticized for potentially inciting communal divisions.

Similarly, In the United States, the dissemination of unfounded claims by former President Donald Trump and his allies has contributed to societal polarisation, culminating in significant real-world consequences, including the Capitol insurrection on January 6, 2021. Recently a report by the Center for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH) has raised concerns about the vulnerability of leading artificial intelligence (AI) image generators to manipulation, which could result in the creation of misleading images related to elections. The report claims that in 41 percent of cases, AI picture generators can produce misleading images that represent things like candidate health problems or electoral fraud. This problem is compounded by additional AI-driven scams aimed at political supporters, such as false social media adverts and fraudulent item offers, making it more difficult to detect legitimate information in an era of increased political polarisation and distrust in mainstream media.

The Election Commission of India’s lack of action on these pressing issues reflects a worrisome disregard for the challenges of digital campaigning, such as micro-targeting and the influence of social media, thereby risking the integrity of the electoral process.

Despite ongoing efforts by the industry to curb political misinformation, the study tested platforms like Midjourney, Stability AI’s DreamStudio, OpenAI’s ChatGPT Plus, and Microsoft Image Creator, and found that all were capable of producing deceptive content concerning U.S. presidential candidates or voting security. The CCDH report observed that while some content moderation measures have been implemented, they remain inadequate to fully safeguard against the generation and dissemination of election disinformation. Highlighting the difficulty in enforcing existing rules against misleading content, the report calls for enhanced cooperation between AI companies and researchers to bolster the integrity and security of these technologies in anticipation of upcoming U.S. elections. Concurrently, Midjourney, an AI image generation platform, is contemplating a ban on AI-generated images of political figures, including President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump. Revealed by CEO David Holz on Discord, this proposed ban is part of broader industry efforts to mitigate misinformation, reflecting similar initiatives by other tech leaders aimed at restricting misleading content.

Both instances highlight the strategic use of AI and digital platforms to amplify political messages, influencing public discourse and potentially swaying electoral outcomes. Regulatory challenges include the need for stringent measures to prevent the misuse of AI and digital communication tools in spreading misinformation. Strengthening frameworks governing electoral communications and ensuring adherence to norms promoting unity and factual accuracy are critical.

These examples underscore the urgency of enhanced regulatory oversight, improved cybersecurity measures, and robust public education campaigns to enhance information literacy among voters. As the elections approach, both nations face the task of navigating these complex issues to safeguard democratic processes and ensure fair electoral outcomes.

As the world prepares for the pivotal 2024 elections in India and the United States, the integration and impact of AI on electoral processes highlight a blend of innovation and contention. The misuse of AI in micro-targeting and spreading misinformation intensifies societal divisions, requiring updated regulatory frameworks and collaborative efforts across various sectors to uphold democratic values and ensure the integrity of elections.

Strengthening democratic processes demands a concerted effort to harness technological advancements while mitigating associated risks. Upholding the security, fairness, and transparency of elections necessitates not only regulatory and technological intervention but also fostering an informed and discerning electorate. This holistic approach is crucial in safeguarding the sanctity of democratic institutions and ensuring that the electoral process reflects the will of the people.

Riya Kothavale is Research Fellow with the Sixteenth Council

References :
● https://counterhate.com/research/fake-image-factories/
● https://www.financialexpress.com/india-news/viksit-bharat-sampark-whatsa
pp-message-from-pm-modi-sparks-row-congress-says-misuse-of-govt-machi
nery/3429026/
● https://edition.cnn.com/2024/03/06/tech/ai-images-election-misinformation/i
ndex.html
● https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/18/world/asia/india-election-ai.html
● https://www.firstpost.com/tech/midjourney-to-ban-biden-trump-images-ahea
d-of-2024-us-elections-fearing-ai-generated-misinformation-13706932.html
● https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2024/01/ai-democracy-election-year-2024
-disinformation-misinformation/
● https://www.livemint.com/news/india/fake-whatsapp-message-circulating-on
-lok-sabha-elections-2024-schedule-says-ec-11708759373214.html
● https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/misinformation/disinformation-unprecedente
d-threat-2024-election-rcna134290
● https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2024/03/26/americans-use-of-chat
gpt-is-ticking-up-but-few-trust-its-election-information/
● https://www.brennancenter.org/election-misinformation#:~:text=Election%2
0 misinformation%20is%20a%20 danger,and%20 participate%20in%20political%20 processes.